How To Read A Small-Group Renewal Letter
Sixty to ninety days before the plan year, the carrier sends a letter. Here is what each number means, what you can change, and the four questions to ask before you sign it.

A small-group renewal letter shows the current and proposed monthly rates by tier (employee, employee + spouse, employee + children, family) or by age band, any plan-design changes (deductible, copays, network), the percentage increase, and the deadline to accept, change or decline. Fully insured small groups in most states are community-rated, so the increase reflects the carrier's statewide trend and your group's age mix — not your claims. Level-funded and large groups are experience-rated, so claims matter. Market the group every year; the renewal is a starting offer.
The Parts Of The Letter
Rate Action
The headline percentage. Mercer projects +8.2% per employee in 2027 after plan changes (+11% with none); a renewal above that deserves marketing. Ask whether the figure is the composite or the per-tier change — family tiers often move more.
Age-Banded Vs Composite
Most small groups under the ACA are age-banded: each employee's rate depends on age, so a workforce that got a year older renews higher even with zero trend. Composite rates average the group; ask which one you are looking at.
Plan Changes
Carriers sometimes "map" you to a different plan when yours is discontinued. Check deductible, out-of-pocket maximum, copays, drug tiers and the network. A 5% rate increase with a $1,000 deductible jump is not a 5% increase.
Deadlines And Participation
Acceptance deadlines, the employer contribution requirement (often 50% of the employee rate) and minimum participation (often 70% of eligible employees, with waivers for other coverage). Falling below either can trigger non-renewal.
What The Percentage Means In Dollars
Renewal Impact Calculator
Arithmetic only: premium × 12 × increase; employer share applied to that. Mercer projects +8.2% per employee in 2027 after plan changes. Your letter's percentage is what counts; this shows what it adds up to.
Market This RenewalWhere That Money Could Go Instead
Increase on the letter vs the same group at Mercer's projected +8.2% — at your inputs.
Three Moves Before Signing
- Market the group: the carriers we're appointed with in your state quote against the letter.
- Level-fund: fixed monthly cost with a possible refund if claims run low (38% of covered workers at small firms are in level-funded plans — KFF 2026).
- ICHRA: a defined allowance ends the renewal letter; employees pick individual plans.
Four Questions Before You Sign
- What did the rest of the market do? Every carrier that writes small groups in your state should quote; we market the group in parallel with the renewal.
- Would level-funding fit? 38% of covered workers at small firms are now in level-funded plans (KFF 2026) — fixed monthly cost with a possible surplus refund, for groups with good experience.
- Would an ICHRA beat it? If individual-market premiums in your counties are below the group rate, a fixed allowance may cost less — see the group-vs-ICHRA calculator.
- Is the Section 125 plan in place? If employees pay their share after tax, you are leaving 7.65% FICA on the table every payroll — see Section 125.
Mercer, Aug 2026; KFF 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey; Rev. Proc. 2026-26.