Section 125: The Savings Are Real. The Gimmicks Are Not.
A cafeteria plan is the one piece of the tax code that pays employers to offer benefits. Here is exactly what it does, what it requires, what it saves, and the "wellness overlay" version the IRS has already ruled taxable.

A Section 125 cafeteria plan is a written plan that lets employees pay for qualified benefits — health, dental, vision, group-term life up to $50,000, supplemental insurance, a health FSA and a dependent-care FSA — through pre-tax salary reductions. The employee's reduction avoids federal income tax and 7.65% FICA; the employer avoids its matching 7.65% FICA (and FUTA) on the reduced wages. The price of admission is a plan document, annual irrevocable elections, and nondiscrimination testing. Owners of pass-through entities generally cannot participate.
What It Saves, Line By Line
| Annual pre-tax contributions (20 × $500 × 12) | $120,000 |
| Employer FICA saved (7.65%) | $9,180 |
| Less: plan document and administration (est. $5/participant/month + $500 setup) | −$1,700 |
| Employer net, year one | $7,480 |
Employee side: $120,000 × (22% federal + 7.65% FICA) ≈ $35,580 in tax not paid, spread across 20 people. Illustrative; your bracket, state and admin fees vary. FUTA savings on the first $7,000 of wages are small and omitted.
Qualified Benefits
- Employee share of medical, dental, vision premiums (premium-only plan)
- Group-term life up to $50,000 (§79)
- Accident, hospital indemnity, critical illness premiums (see tax note below)
- Health FSA — 2026 limit $3,400, carryover $680; 2027 not yet released
- Dependent-care FSA — $7,500 from 2026 under the 2025 budget law
- HSA contributions through payroll
Not Allowed
- Individual health policies (use an ICHRA or QSEHRA instead)
- Long-term care insurance
- Deferred compensation other than a 401(k)
- Participation by >2% S-corp shareholders, partners, LLC members taxed as partners, sole proprietors
What It Requires
A Written Plan Document
No document, no plan: elections become taxable (Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.125-1(c)). Adopt before the first pre-tax deduction.
Irrevocable Annual Elections
Employees elect once a year and may change mid-year only for permitted status changes — marriage, birth, job change, cost or coverage changes (Treas. Reg. §1.125-4).
Nondiscrimination Testing
Eligibility, contributions-and-benefits, and the 25% key-employee concentration test; health FSAs also face §105(h), dependent-care FSAs the 55% test. A "simple cafeteria plan" safe harbor exists for employers with 100 or fewer employees who make a required contribution.
The "Wellness Overlay" The IRS Already Ruled On
In recent years promoters have pitched employers a "Section 125 wellness" or "preventive care management" program: employees pre-tax a large monthly amount (often $1,000+) into a fixed-indemnity policy, the policy pays most of it back each month as a "wellness benefit" for telehealth calls or webinars, and the pitch says take-home pay stays the same while FICA falls for everyone. Promoters often keep a share of the "savings."
- "Employees get a raise with no change in pay"
- "Wellness payments are tax-free"
- "IRS-approved"; generic legal opinion; NDA
- Employer FICA savings on $12,000+ per employee per year
- Promoter paid from the savings
- CCA 202323006 (2023): wellness indemnity payments made without regard to actual medical expenses are wages subject to income tax, FICA and FUTA
- March 2024: Treasury did not finalize new tax rules but stated in the preamble that existing law already denies the §105 exclusion for such payments; IR-2024-65 warned employers again
- Earlier CCAs (2016–2017) and Rev. Ruls. 2002-3 / 2002-80 reached the same result
- Exposure: back FICA and withholding, 20% accuracy penalty, interest, amended W-2s and 941s
Sources: Groom Law Group on CCA 202323006; The Tax Adviser, Nov 2023; BDO on IR-2024-65; Steptoe, June 2026 (promoters still active in 2026); Aflac / Alston & Bird wellness-scheme advisory; California Department of Insurance, July 2025 issued a cease-and-desist against a related "small employee benefit plan" scheme.
Our Position
NovaVida Benefits does not sell pre-tax wellness or preventive-care indemnity overlays, and we will tell you why if a competitor pitches one. The payroll-tax savings we model come only from a premium-only plan, FSAs and HSA payroll contributions — the versions that survive an audit. Fixed-indemnity products we place are set up after-tax so their benefits are tax-free, or pre-tax with full disclosure that benefits above unreimbursed medical expenses are taxable.
Run The Compliant Savings Calculator Set Up A Section 125 Plan